Best Pizza in Staten Island, NY | Casa Ninos Pizza Bar
We are open daily from 10:30 AM to 9:00 PM Call to Order: 718.948.0440
Voted Best of Staten Island

Best Pizza Staten Island

"Voted Best Of by Highlighting Staten Island"

Casa Ninos Pizza Bar serves artisanal, scratch-made wood-fired pizza and traditional Italian cuisine on Staten Island's South Shore. Serving families and events across Arden Heights, Rossville, Eltingville, Great Kills, Annadale, and Huguenot daily.

VIP Perks

Join the VIP Text Club

Subscribe to receive exclusive weekly pizza specials, secret discounts, and local rewards delivered directly to your phone!

Weekly Perks & Hidden Coupon Codes!

Cancel anytime. Standard text rates apply.

Join Now to Unlock Perks
Staten Island South Shore Hub: Arden Heights Rossville Eltingville Great Kills Annadale Huguenot
Hot Values

Everyday Menu Deals

Prepared fresh, available daily for pickup or rapid local delivery.

Most Popular

The Crazy 8 Special

A massive crowd pleaser including 8 traditional NY Slices (Medium Cheese Pie), 8 Crispy Wings, 8 garlic knots, and 8 mozzarella sticks.

Catering Box $31.88+
Pizza Night

The Real Deal

Feed the entire family with 2 Medium hand-tossed NY Cheese Pies, 10 hot fresh garlic knots, and an ice-cold 2 Liter Soda of choice.

Value Combo $27.00+
Premium Dining

Dine-in 4-Course Dinner

Enjoy structured luxury in our dining room with individual portions of Baked Clams (appetizer), Penne Pomodoro (pasta), Chicken Francese or Eggplant Parm (entrées), finished with Cannoli and Coffee.

Family Style $25.00 PP
Exclusive Venue

Host Your Special Occasion in Our Private Dining Space

Planning a Baptism, Communion, Confirmation, Graduation, milestone Birthday, or customized Baby Shower? Our beautiful private party space on Arthur Kill Road is designed to serve up to 50 guests with delicious scratch-prepared family-style Italian packages.

No Room Rental Fee
Custom Buffet Menus
Wine & Draft Bar option
Sizing up to 50 people
Guest Walkthroughs

Video Highlights

See how our South Shore neighbors celebrate communions, birthdays, and anniversaries!

Authentic NY Slices & Platters on Staten Island's South Shore

Looking for the best pizza in Staten Island, NY? Look no further than Casa Ninos Pizza Bar on Arthur Kill Road. We craft each hand-tossed classic pie with fresh ingredients, local cheeses, and simmered plum marinara sauce in our high-temperature stone ovens. We proudly serve our friends and neighbors throughout the South Shore communities, delivering to Arden Heights, Rossville, Eltingville, Great Kills, Annadale, and Huguenot daily.

• Celiac-Friendly GF Options • Seats up to 50 People • Serves Wine & Beer • Family Owned Since 1997

Casa Ninos

Bringing Staten Island the rich culinary heritage of authentic Italian home-cooking and stone-oven pizzas since 1997. We gladly welcome corporate and school accounts.

© 2026 Casa Ninos. All Rights Reserved.

Service & Delivery Areas

We deliver hot, premium pizza and catering trays straight to your door across Arden Heights, Rossville, Eltingville, Great Kills, Annadale, and Huguenot. Minimum delivery charges may apply.

Contact & Bookings

1281 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312

Phone: 718.948.0440

Open Daily: 10:30 AM to 9:00 PM

Skip to content